Wilson Would Expel Illegal Immigrants From Schools : Politics: Saying state can't afford to educate them, he clarifies stand on Prop. 187. Brown charges hypocrisy.

• Share via

SACRAMENTO — Answering a question he has avoided for more than a year, Gov. Pete Wilson said Thursday that he would favor expelling illegal immigrants from the public schools if the U.S. Supreme Court allows it.

The Republican governor said the state cannot afford the estimated $1.5 billion it costs to educate more than 300,000 illegal immigrants now attending kindergarten through 12th-grade classes.

“We cannot educate every child from here to Tierra del Fuego,” Wilson said at a news conference in the Capitol.

In general, the Republican governor has backed Proposition 187--an anti-illegal immigration measure on the November ballot--but until Thursday had not taken a stand on the initiative’s most explosive provisions, which would bar illegal immigrants from the state’s schools and require educators to check on the citizenship status of all students and their parents.

Wilson had said he favored the measure as a way to provoke a legal challenge to a 1982 U.S. Supreme Court decision prohibiting states from denying illegal immigrants a public education.

When pressed Thursday to explain what he would do if the Supreme Court upheld the initiative, Wilson said: “We implement the law.”

A Wilson spokeswoman later clarified the governor’s comments, saying Wilson would prefer to see Proposition 187 coupled with a stronger federal effort to deport illegal immigrants so that children barred from schools do not remain in this country. But ultimately, the aide said, the governor supports the education provisions of the proposition as written.

Wilson’s comments came as the immigration issue re-emerged at the forefront of his reelection campaign against Democrat Kathleen Brown.

Brown opposes Proposition 187. Removing children from the schools, she said Thursday, would be likely to result in “more trouble, more gangs, more guns, more graffiti and more cost to the taxpayers.”

In Orange County, Latino leaders reacted with anger to the governor’s position.

“What is surprising is the depth of his strike against innocent children,” said Amin David, president of Los Amigos de Orange County. “They’re here because of their parents and essentially they are the innocent victims. This is his meanness, the mean-spirited side of the governor showing through.”

Another community leader, Arturo Montez, president of the Santa Ana chapter of the League of United Latin American Citizens, said Wilson’s reference to “Tierra del Fuego”--Land of the Flames--smacks of “bigotry, hate and ignorance.”

“It’s interesting,” Montez said, “that here was the guy who, when he was the mayor of San Diego, didn’t have any problem with people from Tierra del Fuego. And, when he was (U.S.) senator and the crops were rotting in the fields and there was no people to pick crops in California, they went to Tierra del Fuego for help. And, when he’s behind in the polls, he again goes to Tierra del Fuego. But this time, he puts things in the fuego (flame).”

In contrast to Wilson’s use of immigration as a campaign issue, David praised Texas Gov. Ann Richards, who presides in a state that also borders Mexico, but “has not any of the so-called problems that California has.”

Wilson “should visit Mexico,” David said, “and understand how the economies of Mexico and California are intertwined. In Texas, they have a tremendous number of miles of border, but they do not raise the same specter of proposed law. Instead, they find ways of working together.”

John Palacio, Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund program manager in Santa Ana, said, “the danger is that while politicians like the governor fight about numbers, it’s still the California taxpayer who loses if 187 passes. I said this because regardless of the actual cost of legal or illegal immigration might be, it would pale by comparison, if (the measure) passes.”

Palacio said passage of the initiative would mean an estimated $15 billion loss in existing state and federal funds for such things as education and welfare, the equivalent of an additional $1,600 tax for every California family.

Campaigning Thursday in Los Angeles, Brown stepped up her charge that Wilson has been a hypocrite on the issue.

She cited letters that Wilson, then a U.S. senator, wrote in 1987 to President Ronald Reagan and his attorney general, Edwin Meese, complaining that the Immigration and Naturalization Service was making it too difficult for Mexican farm workers to enter the country to pick crops.

Brown also blasted Wilson for trying now to curtail health services to illegal immigrants even though he voted as a senator to provide them. And she showed an informational videotape featuring Wilson in which the state encourages non-citizens to apply for government benefits.

“Pete Wilson votes to impose health care mandates--and now he campaigns against them,” Brown said. “He cut a hole in the fence to allow millions of illegal immigrants in, and now he wants to patch that hole because that’s what the polls tell him to do.”