katero
Jun 23, 2026

The catastrophic mistake Nancy Guthrie investigation suffered in its early days: report

Email Page Six

trending now

Skip to main content Why Brooklyn Beckham is ‘fuming’ over parents David and Victoria’s Father’s Day posts: report Why Brooklyn Beckham is ‘fuming’ over parents David... Keke Palmer gives cheeky update on Sean Evans romance after NYC date Keke Palmer gives cheeky update on Sean Evans romance after NYC... Will Arnett snaps at Jason Bateman over Amy Poehler question: ‘None of your business’ Will Arnett snaps at Jason Bateman over Amy Poehler question:... Nancy Guthrie ransom note reportedly apologizes for kidnapping death, demands millions for body Nancy Guthrie ransom note reportedly apologizes for kidnapping... ‘Ferris Bueller’ star hints at bad blood on set as she reveals why she ditched Hollywood ‘Ferris Bueller’ star hints at bad blood on set as... Savannah Guthrie breaks down on ‘Today’ while addressing mom Nancy’s suspected death in ransom note Savannah Guthrie breaks down on ‘Today’ while... Kenny Chesney tells Bill Maher the key reason he refuses to tell his listeners how to vote Kenny Chesney tells Bill Maher the key reason he refuses to tell... Inside Kylie Jenner and Timothée Chalamet’s romantic Hamptons escape Inside Kylie Jenner and Timothée Chalamet’s romantic...

SHOP NOW

Shop Prime Day like a star with deals on A-list beauty favorites: Crest, Charlotte Tilbury and more Celebrity News

The catastrophic mistake Nancy Guthrie investigation suffered in its early days: report

By Riley Cardoza Published June 22, 2026, 11:07 a.m. ET

See more of our coverage in your search results.

Add Page Six on Google

Officials searching for Nancy Guthrie made a major mistake in the early days of the investigation, according to a new report.

The Pima County Sheriff’s Department and the FBI allegedly blew a chance to find the 84-year-old’s kidnappers in early February, sources told Air Mail.

The outlet claimed Saturday that on Feb. 1, hours after Savannah Guthrie’s mom was reported missing from her Arizona home, a potentially credible ransom note was sent — as was reported by media outlets at the time.

Savannah Guthrie with her mother Nancy Guthrie in the TODAY show studio. 8
Officials investigating Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance reportedly blew their chance to find the 84-year-old (pictured above in June 2023) alive in the search’s early days. Nathan Congleton/NBC via Getty Images
Two FBI agents walking down a road during a search for Nancy Guthrie. 8
Sources close to the investigation told Air Mail the Pima County Sheriffs Department and the FBI flubbed their response to a potentially credible ransom note. California Post

Explore More

Savannah Guthrie breaks down on ‘Today’ while addressing mom Nancy’s suspected death in ransom note

Nancy Guthrie ransom note apologizes for kidnapping death, demands millions for body: report

Search for Nancy Guthrie reignites in Mexico after anonymous tip about ‘grave’

The alleged kidnappers, who provided accurate details about Nancy’s outfit at the time of her disappearance, and the damaged floodlight in her Tucson backyard, requested $4 million in Bitcoin by Feb. 5.

The note, which reportedly dubbed Nancy “safe but scared,” ended with the words, “Or else.”

Instead of paying the full sum and potentially tracking down the kidnapper when the Bitcoin was turned into cash — and giving the money back to the Guthrie family — officials used a “tickling the wire” tactic.

Investigators sent $152 to the Bitcoin address, hoping this amount would be withdrawn and present them with new leads.

Savannah Guthrie sitting with her mother Nancy Guthrie. 8
Savannah Guthrie’s mom (pictured above in 2020) was reported missing on Feb. 1. savannahguthrie/Instagram
A banner with messages of support and a photo of Nancy Guthrie is displayed on a fence. 8
A ransom note sent hours later called her “safe but scared” and requested $4 million. James Keivom for NY Post

Want more celebrity and pop culture news?

Start your day with Page Six Daily.

Thanks for signing up!

This move, however, did not “tempt” the alleged kidnapper, who was captured in chilling security camera footage from Nancy’s home, and the Bitcoin sat untouched.

On Feb. 6, an email from the same I.P. address arrived and, according to sources close to the case, read as “sputtering,” “labored” and “less confident” than the last.

The individual shared an “apology” for Nancy’s inadvertent death, as well as a request that a ransom payment be made for the return of her body.

The outlet claimed, “The task force had to throw up their hands in dismay and concede that … nothing in the collections of carefully analyzed notes had gotten them any closer to finding the culprits. … It was too late. The damage had been done.”

Other posts