SCOTUS delivers a win for common sense with ruling on women’s sports — but activists say the war isn’t over
- US News
- World News
- Page Six
- Sports
- Post Sports+
- Sports Betting
- Business
- Opinion
- Entertainment
- Shopping
- Lifestyle
- Health
- Real Estate
- Alexa
- Media
- Tech
- Science
- Astrology
- Video
- Photos
- Pod Force One
- NY POSTcast
Switch between CA and NY editions here.
EditionRecommended
Skip to main content
Kirsten Fleming
OpinionSCOTUS delivers a win for common sense with ruling on women’s sports — but activists say the war isn’t over
By Kirsten Fleming Published June 30, 2026, 7:28 p.m. ETSee more of our coverage in your search results.
Add The New York Post on GoogleThe Supreme Court just handed down a huge win for biological truth and common sense.
In a 6-3 opinion Tuesday, the court upheld state bans on biological males playing in female sports, ruling against challenges in West Virginia and in Idaho.
And for many athletes turned activists, including former college swimmers Riley Gaines and Paula Scanlan and retired pro soccer player Elizabeth Eddy, it feels like a sweet victory.
“I’m so thankful,” Eddy told me.
5
They all used the same word: “vindicated.” But, they acknowledge, there’s still more to be done. The game is still being played.
More From Kirsten Fleming
Hakeem Jeffries handed himself over to the DSA on a plate, and the comrades will gladly eat him for breakfast
Dave Portnoy reveals what could end his feud with Roger Goodell — and the Barstool figure he blames for nearly getting him canceled
Gross misinformation & TikTok dances about murderer Karmelo Anthony keep piling up — with the ladies of ‘The View’ egging it all on
“This ruling just means that having a sports category solely for women isn’t unconstitutional. It doesn’t mean that states have to make the women’s category exclusive to real women. It just means it’s not illegal if they do so,” Gaines said.
There are currently 27 states that have banned biological males from women’s sports.
5
Tuesday’s decision is another bulwark against the regressive argument that men can simply choose to be female, take some hormones and be granted a key to women’s spaces and competition.
It’s also a rebuke of the far left progressives’ notion that this presents no safety issue or physical disadvantage for girls.
But let’s remember how far we’ve come since this illiberal and oppressive fog settled down on our society.
“Go back to 2020 … when institutions, corporations, universities and governing bodies, and even courts began to pretend that reality was somehow up for debate,” said Gaines, the former University of Kentucky swimmer.
She recounted how, at her 2022 confirmation hearing, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, one of today’s dissenters, “couldn’t answer the question of what is a woman because she’s ‘not a biologist.'”
Indeed, this has been a hard fought battle in which advocates risked everything to stand up and say what we’ve known since the dawn of time: Men and women are biologically different, and men have a physical advantage.
Sex matters.
5
The issue came to a head in 2021 when UPenn men’s swimmer Will Thomas reintroduced himself as Lia Thomas and joined the women’s team.
His new teammates were essentially told: You will like it or else.
And If they had a problem with a 6-foot-4 biological man, his genitalia intact, having access to their locker room? Or with him being given the ability to compete — and dominate? Seek counseling, the school urged.
That social pressure and groupthink kept teammates and competitors quiet for a while. First Scanlan spoke out anonymously. Then Gaines, publicly. Not long after, Scanlan unmasked herself.
“We were told we were bigots,” said Scanlan, who is now a Senior Fellow at the American Principles Project. She is certainly celebrating the win, but also wonders, “Why did it take so long to take for the adults in the room to acknowledge what we knew back then as teenagers?”
5
Even before we knew Thomas’ name, the issue had quietly been bubbling over in Connecticut, where two boys started identifying as girls and beating all the female runners. Four of those runners bravely came together to mount a bumpy and lengthy legal battle that is still unresolved.
Gaines, who now hosts “The Riley Gaines” show on Outkick, says she would be “remiss” to not go even further back and credit the women who fought to make Title IX a reality.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s opinion underscored the need to respect both female and trans athletes. But the justice, who has coached his own two daughters in hoops, also offered insight into why women shouldn’t be expected to sacrifice their ambition on the altar of inclusion.
“Sports are highly competitive and generally zero sum,” he wrote for the majority. “Women and girls who play sports care deeply about all of those things. They obsess about them. They spend extraordinary time and effort to train in the heat and in the cold.”
5
The jubilation is somewhat tempered by media framing. NBC published an article after the decision, saying it delivers “another major blow to LGBTQ rights.” A CBS tweet called it the “latest setback for transgender rights.”
It’s a stark reminder that some institutions and politicians still feel the need to sing the song and do the dance that a small group of activists demand: that the idea of kindness to boys matters more than fairness to girls.
And yet, this was an 80/20 issue that forced many liberals to move center right and even vote for Trump.
But I take heart in Eddy’s perspective. After writing a compassionate op-ed last fall about the need to maintain the integrity of single sex sports, she was publicly blasted by some teammates.
However, “a lot of my peers privately offered support,” she told me. Some people simply aren’t ready to say the truth out loud. Hopefully this empowers the ones still whispering.
Filed under Read Next Supreme Court didn't end the birthright-citizen battle —...Columnists
-
Kirsten Fleming
SCOTUS delivers a win for common sense with ruling on women’s sports — but activists say the war isn’t over
-
Nicole Gelinas
Mamdani is socializing housing in NYC, costing taxpayers billions
-
Daniel McCarthy
Bill Maher got the award, but Trump’s free-speech impact is the real prize
See All Columnists
Covers
Today's Cover
Front Cover Back Cover
Flip for back cover
Browse Covers
Trending Now on NYPost.com
-
This story has been shared 96,214 times.
96,214
Mystery of explosive diarrhea parasite outbreak in the US — as experts try to figure out what’s causing it
-
This story has been shared 64,641 times.
64,641
Cops who busted smiling sisters Cookie and Kitty offer hint at motive for Texas mom’s murder
-
This story has been shared 57,383 times.
57,383
Chilling photo shows bloodied Texas mom after allegedly being stabbed by twisted teen Cookie
Image gallery
More Stories
Page Six
‘The Devil Wears Prada 2’ is now streaming — Here’s how to watch at home
Decider
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Louis C.K.: Ridiculous’ On Netflix, The Comedian Slowly, Crudely, Comes To Grip With The Inevitability Of Mortality
NYPost
Mystery of explosive diarrhea parasite outbreak in the US — as experts try to figure out what’s causing it
© 2026 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved Terms of Use Subscription Terms Privacy Notice SitemapYour California Privacy Rights
Erling Haaland, a striker so good he doesn’t even need to touch the ball
FIFA World
Cup 2026
LIVE
Mexico vs Ecuador24s ago
France Beat SwedenNorway AdvancesBracketPlayers to WatchAnalysisErling Haaland, a striker so good he doesn’t even need to touch the ball

Erling Haaland is Norway's strike warrior Julian Finney - FIFA/FIFA via Getty Images
By Stuart James and Liam TharmeJune 30, 2026 8:38 pm EDT UpdatedIt had to be him.
Even during that curious period in the first half when you had to remind yourself that he was still on the pitch, there was a sense of inevitability that Erling Haaland would end up leaving his mark on Norway’s first World Cup knockout match since 1998.
Goals are the currency that Haaland trades in and his stock couldn’t be any higher in that respect. He is, quite simply, a sure thing when it comes to putting the ball in the back of the net.
Haaland has scored in each of his last 13 competitive appearances for Norway, including five in three matches at his first World Cup and the winner against Ivory Coast today. The broader numbers are astonishing: 60 goals in 53 caps for Norway. To put that record into perspective, it’s the best goals-per-game ratio of any player who has scored 50 or more for their country in the last century.
A bit more context? How about the fact that Haaland reached 60 international goals in 69 fewer appearances than Lionel Messi and 77 fewer than Cristiano Ronaldo?

But it’s not just about the goals. It’s the way he scores, too.
Haaland doesn’t do dribbling, stepovers or drop his shoulder. An elastico? He’d probably tie his hair back with that. He doesn’t shift the ball out of his feet to create half a yard of space before shooting. Haaland doesn’t take a touch full stop. He just pulls the trigger.
All five of his goals at the World Cup have been one-touch finishes. In fact, each and every one of his 14 shots registered across the games against Iraq, Senegal and Ivory Coast has been a first-time effort on goal.

Call it economical. Call it efficient. Call it instinct. Call it ruthless. Call it keeping the game simple. Call it whatever you want, but Haaland is the most natural out-and-out goalscorer of his generation. Whether he’s playing for Manchester City, or for a country that has a population of less than six million people, doesn’t change that in the slightest.
“He has something that maybe you can’t train so much – the sniff for goals, the feeling that the ball will land at your feet, or in that movement, and I think that is his biggest strength,” Norway’s head coach Stale Solbakken said on the eve of the Ivory Coast game. But he then proceeded to reel off a list of other qualities, including his physicality: Solbakken attributed that, with a smile, to Haaland’s mother, an elite track and field athlete, rather than his father, who played alongside Solbakken for Norway in the 1990s.
Either way, the sporting genes were strong in the Haaland family. The end result is the best footballer the country has ever produced and a player unlike any other in the modern game.
“He’s unique, he’s one of a kind and we’re so lucky to have him,” Kristian Thorstvedt told The Athletic after Norway’s 2-1 win which set up a last-16 tie against Brazil. “I’ve known him for so many years and he’s the same guy he’s always been outside the pitch, and he’s got the same mentality he’s always had on the pitch. He’s phenomenal.”
Watching Haaland for the first time must be a strange experience for the uninitiated. There are times when it feels as though anything other than goalscoring is largely irrelevant to him.
What You Should Read Next
Norway edged a game in which wingers made the difference. That may be a problem for Brazil
Antonio Nusa scored an excellent goal from the wing but both sides showed how dangerous they are when attacking from wide positions
After 140 seconds against Ivory Coast, Haaland connected with a header. Then he walked a lot, jogged a bit and sprinted occasionally to press an Ivory Coast defender.
The ball? Haaland didn’t come into contact with it again for another 27 minutes and 54 seconds. There’s a lot you could do in that time, including run 10,000 metres if your name is Joshua Cheptegei.
Essentially, a football match was taking place around him, which is increasingly typical of the role of the modern centre forward: stay high, occupy the centre-backs, leave space for others, and don’t run outside the width of the penalty area.
Mikel Oyarzabal knows the drill well. The Real Sociedad striker failed to touch the ball in the opening half an hour of Spain’s World Cup group game against Cape Verde.
Except the difference is that Oyarzabal isn’t Haaland – an instantly recognisable superstar of the game.
Indeed, if you were among the 69,665 people at the AT&T Stadium in Dallas on Tuesday and new to the sport, you could have been forgiven for wondering in that first 30 minutes – maybe even the opening hour, actually – what all the fuss is about with this 6ft 5in, 207lb blond-haired pony-tailed striker.
What does he actually do?
Well, for a start, he made four clearances, which was reflective of the fact that he had more touches in his own penalty area (seven) than in the Ivory Coast box (five).

“He’s important with our set pieces being the man heading the ball out,” Thorstvedt said. “And we know he will always be in front of the goal (at the other end) when we need it.”
Norway did need it here, too. Amad Diallo’s equaliser, after Antonio Nusa had given Norway a first-half lead, had threatened to shift the momentum of the match in Ivory Coast’s favour. Haaland, though, had other ideas. Patrick Berg’s run and cross drew three Ivory Coast players to the ball, leaving Haaland in so much space that he could afford to make a poor connection with his shot and still get the winner.
Erling Haaland has scored with 7.25% of his touches at the 2026 World Cup; among players to have at least 60 touches at a single World Cup (since 1966), no player has scored with a greater proportion. pic.twitter.com/DrmbxAeuFB
— Opta Analyst (@OptaAnalyst) June 30, 2026
“He is the greatest goalscorer in the world, there’s no doubt about that,” Solbakken added. “Today he wasn’t that involved but you know if gets that chance… he scored the winning goal again. His stats are out of this world for the national team.”
But there’s something else, too – something that shines through to anyone who has seen Haaland play at this World Cup, even the opposition managers. “When you watch him, you really feel he’s very proud to play for his country,” Emerse Fae, the Ivory Coast coach, said.
You could see that in the ear-to-ear grin on Haaland’s face when Martin Odegaard was banging the drum in front of the Norway fans after the final whistle and the matchwinner, sitting side by side with his teammates, was proudly ‘rowing’ his country towards the last-16 of the World Cup.
“It’s nice to see that it means so much to all of Norway,” Haaland said. “I think this will change Norway forever.”
Jul 1, 2026Connections: Sports Edition
Spot the pattern. Connect the terms
Find the hidden link between sports terms
Tagged To: Erling HaalandFIFA Men's World CupInternational FootballPremier LeagueSoccer