katero
Jun 24, 2026

Phillies’ lefty bullpen concerns mount as struggling José Alvarado unravels vs. Mets

MLB Latest

Trade Deadline Big BoardPower RankingsDOJ InvestigationInternational Draft ProposalAnalysis

Phillies’ lefty bullpen concerns mount as struggling José Alvarado unravels vs. Mets

José Alvarado of the Philadelphia Phillies throws a pitch in the seventh inning during the game against the New York Mets.

José Alvarado, intended to be part of the high-leverage core of Phillies relievers, has been extremely shaky. Hunter Martin / Getty Images

By Charlotte VarnesJune 19, 2026 Updated

PHILADELPHIA — The difference between an inning-ending strikeout and a multi-run mess for the Phillies came down to a scrape on the baseball.

The top of the seventh seemingly ended when a foul tip was called, with Phillies reliever José Alvarado striding off the mound before further review revealed the ball had hit the dirt by home plate. Alvarado returned, and it took six more pitches for everything to unravel, culminating in Justin Crawford scrambling to the wall in center and the New York Mets’ Marcus Semien sprinting from the batters’ box to third. The Mets, who entered the seventh tied 3-3 with the Phillies, left the inning holding a three-run lead en route to a 6-4 win at Citizens Bank Park.

“In spots like that, I’m always optimistic,” Alvarado said via interpreter Diego D’Aniello, “so I try to remain optimistic and control my mind and stay calm.”

The optimism did not yield much in another difficult outing for Alvarado, whose batting average against rose to .313 and whose ERA increased to 6.58 in 26 innings this season. He has emerged as a question mark in the bullpen, one group with which the Phillies have cultivated real depth.

How did The Miz get this good, this fast?Derek VanRiper and Eno Sarris

Much of that depth, however, is right-handed. Seth Johnson pitched perhaps his best big-league inning on Thursday, striking out two in a 17-pitch inning. Max Lazar was excellent on back-to-back days earlier in the week. Bryse Wilson, who was added to the 40-man roster on Thursday, pitched two innings. They are all righties.

The Phillies entered 2026 with what looked like a strong set of lefties on the Opening Day roster: Alvarado, Tanner Banks, Kyle Backhus and Tim Mayza. Not much has gone to plan for them since then. The group has a 1.64 WHIP (25th in MLB), 4.95 ERA (26th) and a .280 batting average against (30th). As for their individual seasons:

  • Alvarado: 19 earned runs in 26 innings (in 26 innings last season, he gave up just 11, though he was suspended for PED usage in May 2025)
  • Banks: Optioned to Triple A on Thursday; 5.86 ERA in 27 2/3 innings and .328 batting average against after a breakthrough in 2025
  • Backhus: On a rehab assignment in Triple A after going on the injured list with elbow inflammation on April 30; two earned runs in 8 1/3 MLB innings in April
  • Mayza: .213 batting average against, 2.97 ERA in 33 1/3 innings

Other posts