katero
Jun 30, 2026

MLB halfway grades for every American League team: White Sox lead the pack, Mariners, Blue Jays failing

With July and then the All-Star break just around the bend, we're now roughly halfway through the 2026 Major League Baseball regular season. Every team has played at least 81 games and roughly three months of play are behind us, which means it's time to check in on all of MLB's 30 teams. Specifically, we're here to hand out grades to each team based on how the first half of the season has gone to date.

It's not a simple matter of eyeballing the standings. Rather, the grades to come are informed by the standings, the team's underlying performance, and how those two measures compare with reasonable expectations entering the 2026 season. There's no such thing as a good team with a bad grade, but teams that were expected to be good won't be graded as highly as those teams that qualify as "pleasant surprises." The same principle applies to the other, uglier end of the continuum.

We've already graded the National League at the midpoint, and now it's the American League's turn.

MLB halfway grades for every National League team: Dodgers, Braves ace first half, Mets score easy 'F' Dayn Perry
MLB halfway grades for every National League team: Dodgers, Braves ace first half, Mets score easy 'F'
team logo

Athletics: C-

The A's are within hailing distance of first place in the AL West, but that says more about the (very low) quality of the competition. Stated another way, the A's are in contention for the division title despite a sub-.500 record and the second-worst run differential in the AL. The lineup lacks depth, and only the Rockies have a worse team ERA. Still, they're contenders, as absurd as that sounds. Injury concerns are mounting, though. -- Dayn Perry

team logo

Baltimore Orioles: D

They've waffled between a D and an F all season. They haven't won more than three straight games all year and they've lost as many as four straight games only twice. No extended runs in either direction to fully establish them as pretenders or contenders. The American League is mediocrity defined, so the O's are still in the wild-card race, but they didn't sign Pete Alonso to only be on the fringes of contention going into July. The rotation has been much, much better over the last month or so. The offense has been inconsistent at best. Alonso is carrying them and their second most reliable hitter the last few weeks has been No. 9 hitter Blaze Alexander-- Mike Axisa

team logo

Boston Red Sox: D

The good news is that BaseRuns and regular old run differential both say the Red Sox should have a much better record than they have. The bad news is "much better record than they have" means they should be around .500, not much further up the standings. To call this a disappointment after last year's return to the postseason and the active winter would be an understatement. A trendy World Series pick coming into 2026, the Red Sox are more likely to sell at the deadline than not. Is the organization in a better place right now than it was when they fired Chaim Bloom and replaced him with Craig Breslow three years ago? That this is even a fair question is not great. -- Axisa

team logo

Chicago White Sox: A

After losing 121 games two years ago and 102 last season, the White Sox are not only above .500 but are fighting for a division title. That's a monster victory for the franchise. Speaking of victories, landing Munetaka Murakami was an utter coup, Miguel Vargas is blossoming into a star and Colson Montgomery has already hit 20 home runs. There remain questions in the rotation, but this White Sox bunch is clearly ahead of schedule. -- Matt Snyder

team logo

Cleveland Guardians: B

It's simply business as usual for this franchise to be over .500 and in the mix for a division title. This alone means they will not receive a grade worse than a B, and the pitching staff has been worthy of perhaps a better grade. Offensively, though, there's a lot left to be desired here. The Guardians are among the worst in baseball in batting average and OPS. They put the ball in play and steal bases, sure, but they don't generally hit the ball with authority and it's a major concern moving forward. José Ramírez will be back at some point and can move the proverbial needle, but until then, the offense is anemic and holds the team back. -- Snyder

team logo

Detroit Tigers: F

Other posts