katero
Jun 24, 2026

'Consistency is key' for All-Ireland contenders

Story byBBCBBCDavid Mohan - BBC Sport NI journalistSat, June 20, 2026 at 8:07 AM UTC·5 min read

With the All-Ireland Senior Football Championship now into straight knockout territory, eight-time All-Ireland winner Philly McMahon feels "consistency is key" in the race for Sam Maguire.

The former Dublin defender will watch his county take on Donegal at Croke Park on Sunday [13:15 BST] with a place in the quarter-finals up for grabs, and while they go in as underdogs, they face a side that has endured patch form in the championship.

AdvertisementAdvertisement

Following a shock exit from the Ulsster Championship at the hands of Down, Jim McGuinness' men turned on the style in the All-Ireland SFC Round One game away to Kerry, only to be caught again on home turf in the next round by Cork.

The Dubs lost a Leinster final to Westmeath and then fell to Louth - whom they beat in a provincial semi-final - in the opening round of the All-Ireland series before bouncing back with victory over Cavan.

Between the provincial and All-Ireland championships, there are no undefeated teams .

For Donegal, pre-championship favourites, their up and down form has been something of a surprise, but McMahon feels the jeopardy of elimination may help them refocus.

AdvertisementAdvertisement

"They are still a strong outfit with a lot of quality," McMahon told BBC Sport NI's Mark Sidebottom.

"They still went to Killarney and beat Kerry, so if they get past Dublin and a good draw in a quarter-final, they're still where they want to be.

"Their standards are still high. They are inconsistent but still know what works for them, so if they can iron out the issues and wheat's not working for them, they are still a danger and have nothing to fear.

"They've lost to teams who were underdogs, but have nobody to fear at the top table and maybe that is what they need in terms of motivation because the games they have lost, maybe they haven't got that."

Philly McMahon with the Sam Maguire Cup
McMahon won eight All-Ireland titles as a Dublin player [Getty Images]

In the wake of victory over Cavan, Dublin manager Ger Brennan called for this Round Three clash to be played in the more intimate surroundings of Parnell Park, which Dublin last used in the football championship back in 2004 against London.

AdvertisementAdvertisement

Such a scenario was unthinkable during McMahon's playing career when Dublin fans packed out Croke Park, but with attendances dwindling following the end of the county's run of nine All-Ireland titles in 12 years, he feels moving this crunch clash to the 8,500-capacity Donnycarney venue "may have given Dublin that little bit of an edge".

However, Croke Park it is with a much greater attendance expected than the 16,160 who showed up for the Louth game.

'GAA must look at severity of bans'

Dublin were boosted against Cavan by the return of Brennan from his 12-week suspension following an incident with Galway strength and conditioning coach Cian Breathnach McGinn during a league game in March.

AdvertisementAdvertisement

Brennan's return is a "great lift" according to his former teammate who now hopes that will translate into "a bounce against Donegal".

While much debate surrounded the severity of the suspension, with the issue reopened when Donegal boss McGuinness escaped with no sanction from the game against Kerry when appearing to push midfielder Diarmuid O'Connor as tempers flared at half-time in Killarney.

However, McMahon feels the Donegal boss receiving no punishment "isn't the problem here", but Brennan's ban was "too harsh".

"There should be separate punishments for the harshness of the incident.

AdvertisementAdvertisement

Other posts